| NECC 2017-18 | ||
| Mike Pierre | G | Player of the Year, 1st Team |
| Daemond Carter | G | Defensive Player of the Year |
| Rohan Piple | F | All-sportsmanship Team |
| Dan Engelstad | HC | Coach of the Year |
| NECC 2016-17 | ||
| Rayshawn Taylor | G/F | 1st Team |
| Nate Goldsmith | G/F | 2nd Team |
| Mike Pierre | G | 3rd Team |
| Ervin Cook | G | All-sportsmanship Team |
| NECC 2015-16 | ||
| DeShawn Hamlet | F | 1st Team |
| Casey Hall | F | 2nd Team |
| Jackson Amankrah | G | All-sportsmanship Team |
| Dan Engelstad | HC | Coach of the Year |
| NECC 2014-15 | ||
| DeShawn Hamlet | F | Player of the Year, 1st Team |
| Daemond Carter | G | Rookie of the Year |
| Dolapo Olugbile | F | Honorable Mention |
| Dan Engelstad | HC | Coach of the Year |
| NECC 2013-14 | ||
| Dolapo Olugbile | F | Honorable Mention |
| Antoine White | G | Honorable Mention |
| NECC 2012-13 | ||
| Taeshon Johnson | G | 1st Team |
| NECC 2011-12 | ||
| Taeshon Johson | G | 1st Team |
| NECC 2010-11 | ||
| Lance Spratling | G | Player of the Year, 1st Team |
| Taeshon Johnson | G | 2nd Team |
| Ben Naaktgeboren | F | Honorable Mention |
| NECC 2009-10 | ||
| Joe Karnik | F | 1st Team |
| Lance Spratling | G | 2nd Team |
| NECC 2008-09 | ||
| Joe Karnik | F | 1st Team |
| Brendan Kordana | G | Honorable Mention |
| GNAC 1999-2000 | ||
| Chris Farruggio | 2nd Team | |
| CSC 1993-94 | ||
| Dickie Hurley | Player of the Year, 1st Year | |
| Anthony Harvey | 1st Team | |
| Keithly Hicks | 2nd Team |