| 2018 NECC | ||
| John Arancio | SS | 2nd Team |
| Niko D'Agnese | OF | 2nd Team |
| Monte Hogue | P | All-Sportsmanship |
| 2017 NECC | ||
| Anthony Mercuri | DH | 2nd Team |
| Jordan Banks | 1B | All-Sportsmanship |
| 2016 NECC | ||
| Dan Mason | C | 3rd Team |
| Joshua Hay | P | All-Sportsmanship |
| 2015 NECC | ||
| Cody LaBadia | 1B | 2nd Team |
| Richard Rios | UT | Honorable Mention |
| 2014 NECC | ||
| Cody LaBadia | 1B | 1st Team |
| RJ Pingitore | 2B | 1st Team |
| Richard Rios | OF | 2nd Team |
| Chris Nicastro Jr. | SS | Honorable Mention |
| 2013 NECC | ||
| Corey Armstrong | P/1B | Honorable Mention |
| 2012 NECC | ||
| Pat Warrington | OF | 1st Team |
| Cody LaBadia | 1B | 2nd Team |
| 2011 NECC | ||
| Corey Armstrong | 1B | 1st Team |
| Dave Gage | 2B | 1st Team |
| Pat Warrington | OF | 1st Team |
| 2010 NECC | ||
| Eric Wells | C | 1st Team |
| Dan Cook | C | Honorable Mention |
| 2009 NECC | ||
| Eric Wells | C | Honorable Mention |
| Adam Northup | 1B | Honorable Mention |